Around Veterans' Day, 2002, a crack team made its way towards a high-value target located in a farm near Gambrillis, Maryland.
They'd gone in mufti, and waited until the coast was clear before they carried out their plan. In a few minutes, the daring personnel carrying out this special operation had succeeded: "Bill the Goat" was now a prisoner of the United States Military Academy.
A New York Times report shortly afterwards quoted a Navy academy spokesman as saying, "I can confirm that one of our goats is missing. However, we would be surprised that a West Point cadet is involved, given that we have had an agreement for a number of years that mascots will not be stolen."
The Naval Academy soon got a photo showing an Army cadet next to Bill. The cadet was in uniform – albeit he had hidden his identity with a ski mask.
"It behooves us to keep a low profile until the game, but we're trying to keep this lighthearted and not get in anyone's face," the anonymous cadet told the New York Times. "And we want to assure Navy that we've been treating our guest with utmost deference. In fact, he's been putting on weight."
Bill was later returned to the Navy. Plans to shave an "A" for Army on him were not implemented, and the cadets were given amnesty in exchange for coming forward and revealing where they had stashed Bill the Goat.
He was returned before the Army-Navy game. That year, Navy beat Army, 58-12. Since then, the Navy has not lost to Army in the annual game.
That said, since then, the Navy has twice been victimized by operations aimed at this high-value target. In 2007, the Washington Examiner reported that Army cadets again pulled off this masterpiece of pranks, posting the video on YouTube (it was called "Operation Good Shepherd").
Past kidnappings also included the first in 1953, which prompted an order from President Dwight D. Eisenhower for the animal's return. In 1960, the Air Force Academy captured Bill and flew him to a Colorado farm. An A-26 Invader was used as the getaway plane. A 1995 operation by Army cadets resulted in the capture of all three Navy mascots.